
By Jessica Gorman
We don’t have much evidence of the existence of Caroline Reese Etter, mostly just her marker in the old section of the Minden Cemetery. It reads: “Sacred to the memory of Mrs. Caroline C. Etter who died Oct. 1st 1847, aged 26 years, 11 months, and 11 days.”
Caroline was born in September of 1820 and was married to Edward Etter on 23 March 1842 in Minden which was then part of Claiborne Parish. Because Claiborne Parish records were destroyed when the courthouse burned in late 1849, the only record of their marriage is a short announcement in an Alexandria, Virginia newspaper.
You may wonder why their marriage would be announcement in a newspaper in Virginia. Edward Etter was from Washington, D.C. He was likely the son of Joseph and Caroline Etter. Joseph was a watchmaker. Edward was a jeweler. Both Joseph and Caroline died by 1831. Edward would have been about 14 years old. Several of the Etter children moved to New Orleans which may explain how Edward wound up in Minden. Here, he owned a jewelry store and in 1855 was listed among “the principal merchants of Minden.” His store stood on the lot beside the Imperial Hotel building. When Charles Veeder left for California in 1849 and his home was auctioned at sheriff’s sale, Edward Etter was the high bidder.
The announcement of the Etter’s marriage in 1842 is the only documented evidence of who Caroline may have been, other than simply Edward’s wife. It gives her maiden name, Reese. It seems likely that she may have been the daughter of Henry and Mary Reese. The Reese family lived in Georgia prior to their move to Louisiana in the 1830s. They are recorded in Claiborne Parish in 1840 and Bienville Parish in 1850. (Bienville Parish was created from Claiborne Parish in 1848.) By 1860, they had moved on to Jasper County, Texas to the same area where Adam Stewart who had lived on the site that became Minden had moved with his family in the 1830s.
Henry Reese became the primary suspect to be Caroline’s father based on the fact that his was the only local Reese family I was able to find. As I looked closer, I realized other details that seem to connect the dots.
Henry Reese was married to Mary Bonner. I recognized the Bonner name as being the maiden name of Mrs. Mahala Drake, wife of William Abner Drake, the elder of two William Abner Drakes who played a significant role in the development of Minden. At the time of their marriage, Mahala Drake was Mahala Hill, a widow. She had a daughter, Almedia, by her first husband. William Abner Drake and Mahala Hill were married in March 1831 in Walton County, Georgia. The same county where the Reese family was living in 1830. That led me to suspect that Mahala Drake and Mary Reese were related and then I was struck by another realization. Caroline Etter’s grave is right next to Mahala Drake. The clue has been there all along without being recognized.
So far, the evidence is circumstantial but strong. My gut feeling, my theory is that Mahala Drake and Mary Reese were sisters and that Caroline Etter was the daughter of Mary Reese. Wednesday morning it was only known that Caroline was the wife of Edward Etter. By afternoon, even with very limited information, the pieces started falling into place and as they did there was another little detail that jumped out at me. If you follow this column, you may remember that I have mentioned on several occasions how I will often be working on something and realize that particular day is the anniversary of that person’s birth or death. Well, I was working on putting this together on Wednesday. (I’ve said before I write this column by the seat of my pants and that’s really not an exaggeration.) Wednesday was November 11th, obviously Veterans Day, but also Mahala Drake’s birthday.
In this particular situation, it was funny to me to make that realization because for the past three weeks I haven’t written anything. It’s the first time in just over four years that I’ve missed three consecutive weeks. Mostly, there’s been a lot of other work that required my attention but I also needed a little breathing room for myself. Even though I had decided not to let myself feel guilty, I really didn’t want to miss a fourth week. I started working on Caroline Etter and wasn’t sure things were going to come together or if I would end up with nothing to write. While we still don’t know much, I’m glad to know more about another “resident” of the Minden Cemetery and how she may fit into the story of the town. Realizing the significance of the date felt like a little encouragement to go ahead and write what I’ve got even if the story isn’t complete.
(Jessica Gorman is Executive Director of the Dorcheat Historical Association Museum, Webster Parish Historian, President of the Minden Cemetery Association, and an avid genealogist.)